Comma Before Such As: “Such as” is a phrase that sometimes requires a comma and sometimes does not. Using the “such as” clause as an example, you can see whether the sentence’s meaning has changed. If it has, you can decide whether the comma should be placed after it or after the clause. In some cases, commas are used to separate phrases that begin with the word “such as.” On other occasions, the term “for example” is used without a comma. Using commas correctly in the English language can be challenging. As a result, two sentences that appear structurally similar can have significantly different punctuation requirements.
- A sweet taste can be found in desserts, such as frozen yoghurt and candy bars.
- There are vibrantly coloured vegetables, such as Carrots and Eggplant.
As you can see, there is a big difference between these two statements. Just to put it bluntly, all desserts have a sweet taste to them, and only a few vegetables are vibrantly coloured. Whether or not you need commas depends on the significance of the information in the phrase referred to. To put it another way, whether or not the word is restrictive. This means determining whether or not omitting the data in question would result in an incorrect or ambiguous sentence.
- Abortion is frequently prompted by ethical considerations such as religious beliefs.
It is reasonable to assume that the reader will expect you to bring up religion in the following statements if you write it in this manner. It’s a bit restrictive.
- Abortion is primarily motivated by ethical considerations, such as religious beliefs.
The emphasis here is on the ethical considerations, with religion serving as a supporting example. It is non-restrictive.
There are two ways to do this: you can use commas in front of or after the phrase initiated by such as, or you can leave them out entirely. It all varies based on whether or not the information in question is necessary for the sentence and subsequent text. If the answer to that question is no, then “such as” is a non-restrictive (i.e., not essential) clause, and as a result, it must be separated by commas to be correctly formatted. E.g.
- Flowers, such as tulips and daffodils, can be found in abundance in the garden.
If we take out the phrase “such as,” we are left with the sentence “The garden is ablaze with flowers.” Everything about this makes absolute sense on its own. The types of flowers should be specified because it is an explanatory variable detail rather than an essential clause, and as such, it should be accompanied by a comma.
You have such a restrictive clause if the phrase “such as” does not affect the sentence’s meaning. In this case, you should not use the comma to separate the two clauses. E.g.
- Hot climates can be found in countries such as Mali and Senegal.
The sentence “Countries have hot climates” remains unchanged if the phrase “such as Mali and Senegal” is removed from the sentence. Inferring that all countries have hot climates is incorrect, as has been demonstrated time and time again. Therefore, this is a critical phase, and we should not place commas around it to denote its importance.
- Observations on Punctuation
- Why Comma Isn’t Necessary Before Such as?
- Is It Necessary To Put A Comma Before The Word ‘Such As’?
- What Type Of Punctuation Can Be Used After The Phrase, Such As?
- Do You Put A Semicolon After A Phrase Such As?
- Is it possible to begin a sentence with such?
- How Do You Come Up With A Sentence Like That?
- When Is Such As Used In A Sentence?
Much like so many other comma-related questions, the answer is contingent on whether the sentence in question is restrictive or non-restrictive. As soon as it becomes clear that eliminating the phrase will alter the sentence’s meaning, it is considered restrictive, and the comma should not be used. As an alternative, when the expression is removed from the penalty, and it still makes sense, it is considered non-restrictive, and a comma should be used to separate the two parts of the sentence.
- Don’t Use a Comma If You Want to Be Strict.
- Use a comma to denote non-restrictiveness.
- Identifying Particular Instances
It would be of the non-restrictive diverse array if the phrase preceded by the words “including” or “such as” introduces additional information about a noun that is already specific, as in the opening example and the examples that follow.
- The preparation of many technical documents, such as a visa application form, a statement of purpose, and a resume, was required of me.
- Sammy, a friend of mine, has travelled to far-off places, such as Paris, Russia, and the North American continent.
- Musicals with dark, sweeping scores, such as Phantom of the Opera, Elisabeth, and Dracula, are some of my favourites to watch.
Consider removing the phrases that begin with “including” or “such as” from the examples provided above. Would the meaning be the same in both cases?
- I had to put together a large number of technical documents.
- Sammy, a friend of mine, has travelled to faraway lands.
- Musicals with dark, sweeping scores are some of my favourites.
The same concepts are communicated, whether or not examples are provided. What exactly did you prepare? Technology documents. Where did Sammy go on his journey? Countries that are far away. Which musicals are your favourites? Those who are gloomy. Because you can still tell what the sentences are about or what type of thing they are about, you know that the deleted phrases are non-restrictive and that the commas are required.
Note that when a non-restrictive phrase appears in the middle of a sentence, it is separated from the rest of the sentence by commas, both before and after the entire sample phrase. Consider the final comma as a way of bringing the example phrase to a close and resuming the sentence’s train of thought back to the primary independent clause.
Completely right: Birds such as the penguin and the ostrich cannot fly.
This is a limiting phrase following a phrase like that. As a result, we don’t use a comma before phrases like that. The term “such as the penguin and ostrich” is restrictive because we would end up with a false sentence if we were to remove it. This sentence has a problem:
“Birds do not fly,” and birds do fly. Many people do, at least.
The phrase “such as” can be used in various contexts beyond the realm of birds and fish. In writing, it is frequently employed to illustrate a point.
Correct: In the 1940s, big houses, such as farm-style winery houses, were trendy.
Correct: Some herbs, such as chamomile and basil, have been used for hundreds of years or more.
Make sure you don’t forget about this! This means that even if the phrase were removed from the sentence, it would still be valid. So, big houses would have been famous in the 1940s, as well. “As well as the long history of certain herbal plants.
I’ve researched the Internet and am aware of the debate over whether or not to use commas before ‘for example. If the phrase is non-restrictive, a comma is required; otherwise, it is not required. However, there are times when I am still perplexed about what I am doing.
Pay attention to the following sentences – I’d like to know if a comma is required before the words’ for example’ and ‘such as in the following two sentences. Is it possible to determine whether a comma is required before ‘for example’ based on the writer’s intent? Is it possible to use the words’ dogmas, doctrines, and beliefs in the first sentence, rather than ‘beliefs, doctrines, and dogmas’? Is it still necessary to use a comma before a phrase like “such as”?
Humanity has been enslaved by human concepts, such as dogmas, doctrines, theories, and religious convictions.
Using a semicolon to separate two complete sentences closely related; furthermore, it is good to use a semicolon to separate two complete sentences linked by a transition phase such as also, again, consequently, or similarly. Consider the semicolon as a hard punctuation mark or a soft period rather than the colon it is named for.
Yes, you can do that. “Such as” is a synonym for “for example,” but it’s a slightly different way of saying it. It’s not just the University of California system, but also the University of California system, including the University of California system, the University of California system.
Non-restrictive clauses are the only cases in which the phrase “such as” is required to have a prefix. Here’s a hint: Even though commas can be challenging to understand, they do not have to be a source of confusion.
We can use such as to provide an example or examples of what we are discussing. A comma is usually used before a list of models, but this is not always the case. Commas are unnecessary when there is only one example.” There are pineapples, mangoes, and papaya in abundance at this shop.